Putting down the hatchet

Fifteen years ago, I landed my dream job. Well, OK… my dream internship, anyway. I was working for a conservative Christian lobbying group in DC. We were located just eight blocks from the White House, and we were on the front lines of the culture war.

When I arrived in May of that year, I was assigned to work in what they called the Cultural Studies department. As I soon learned, there was only one culture we studied: the gay rights movement. And we didn’t “study” it so much as fight it tooth and nail.

A few weeks into the job, I attended a strategy summit of like-minded lobbying groups. On the agenda: figuring out how to discredit one particular one group we all despised. The stakeholders around the table took turns proposing various tactics, most of which involved some effort to publicly humiliate or otherwise embarrass an important official associated with this group.

For one fleeting moment, it occurred to me: everyone around this table, myself included, would have argued passionately that our political values and beliefs were shaped by our religious convictions. Yet these convictions apparently held no sway over the means we were willing to use to advance our cause.

Personal attacks.

Public humiliation.

Character assassination.

A few weeks later, I was given an assignment: write a booklet defending what we believed was the orthodox view of biblical sexuality against an alternative view being promoted by the gay Christian community and its supporters.

One day, as I was in the middle of this assignment, my boss met me in the hall and handed me a manila folder with Tony Campolo’s name written on it. He looked at me and said, “This is for the booklet. I want you to go after Campolo.”

Tony Campolo is perhaps one of the best-known progressive voices in the evangelical church. The fact that he was a progressive with impeccable evangelical credentials was a source of endless irritation for my colleagues and me. People like Campolo made no sense to us. They were walking contradictions; they weren’t supposed to exist. Theologically, Campolo held the same view of sexuality as we did, yet politically he was a supporter of gay rights. He often criticized people like us for “being tempted into hysterical animosity against gays and lesbians.”

Campolo was a thorn in our side; something had to be done.

So I went back to my desk and opened the folder. To be honest, there wasn’t much to work with. A few pieces of correspondence between Tony and my boss (which mainly served to illustrate how deeply my boss disliked him), a few news clippings… and a photocopy of a flyer purporting to be from a group called Queer Nation. It was advertising a “demonstration of support” in honor of Dr. Campolo.

It wasn’t much, but it was all I had to work with. So I went with “guilt by association.” If his actions earned the praise of a radical group like Queer Nation, I reasoned, then he can’t be up to much good.

A few months later, when I was back at college, the booklet was published. My former employer shipped thousands of copies to supporters across the nation. I made sure my political science advisor got one. (Though he was a registered Democrat, he had gone to bat for me in landing this internship.)

One day, he met me in the hall outside his office. “I read your booklet,” he said. “That part about Campolo… that was a hatchet job.”

It wasn’t angry or accusatory. Just matter of fact. And it was true.

All I could manage to say was, “I know.”

My advisor never said another word about it. He gave me full marks for the internship. But his words have stayed with me ever since.

And you know what the worst part was?

That flyer — the one that gave us our pretext for attacking Campolo—proved to be a hoax. My employer had to print a retraction. In it, they insisted we only meant to illustrate how gay activists take advantage of well-meaning, too-softhearted-for-their-own-good Christians like Campolo.

Which was a lie.

“I want you to go after Campolo.” That’s what my boss had told me when he gave me that manila folder. That’s what motivated me to write what I did. This was no kindly-intended warning. It was a hatchet job.


A lot has changed in the last 15 years. (I don’t think my old employer would ask me back, for one thing.) But here’s what I learned from this experience. If you’re a Christian — left or right, it doesn’t matter — and if your religious convictions lead you into political activism, do not bring Jesus into it unless you’re prepared to let him shape not only the causes you support, but the way you go about it — and above all, the way you treat your political adversaries.

Just because everyone else plays dirty doesn’t mean we get to. It doesn’t change the fact that Jesus told us to do good to our enemies, turn the other cheek, go the second mile. When we’re insulted or attacked, we don’t have the option of retaliation; we’ve cast our lot with a Messiah who refused to fight back when attacked. We don’t have the right to seek power for ourselves and our allies, because our Lord relinquished his claim to power so he could become the servant of all. And he expects his followers to do likewise, to repay insult with kindness, to return evil with good.

Even in politics.


After I graduated college, I was still troubled by what I had done. Yes, a retraction had been printed (albeit a dishonest one), but I still felt the need to set things right. So I wrote to Dr. Campolo, explained who I was, and apologized.

The response I got back was unmitigated grace and forgiveness. Not one hint of malice or resentment. He actually thanked me for reaching out—me, the guy with the hatchet in his hand.

Tony Campolo modeled for me what it looks like when you allow Jesus to shape your political engagement—not only the causes you choose to support, but the way you go about it and how you treat your political adversaries.

So this election day (and every day), may we—left, right, and everyone in between—have spirited, vibrant conversations with those on the other end of the political spectrum. May we stand up and speak out for the causes that are dear to us.

But may we always remember that on the other side of every issue, every debate, and every election is a human being made in God’s image and loved by him every bit as dearly as we are.

42 thoughts on “Putting down the hatchet

  1. All I can say, Ben, is wow… A striking criticism of the political atmosphere in our nation and the way we as Christians get sucked into it.

    I wish I had the quote in front of me but it echoes to the sentiments put forth by various characters in “The Lord of the Rings” when it comes to using the ring for “good”… both Gandalf and Galadriel, immensely powerful forces for good, recognize that imbued in the tools of the enemy is the power to ultimately corrupt even the best of intentions…

    I wouldn’t go so far as some and say it is evil to be involved in politics…but we as Christians must take extra care and discernment before we step into that muck and mire…are we able to resist the pull towards such compromises…or do we risk falling as well?

    Thanks for these excellent words.


    • Thanks Robert. That’s actually one of my favorite scenes in LOTR!

      I’ve come to the conclusion that the best we as Christians can do when we engage in politics is to make sure we’re doing so on behalf of the poor, the vulnerable, etc…and not for own own self-interest or advancement. It’s hardly a guaranteed way to avoid the pitfalls of political engagement, but it’s a start…


  2. Awesome. Thanks for being open and honest, brother. I’ll take a repentant hatchet man any day over, well, anyone unrepentant. 8^)
    You nailed today’s climate. Our hearts beat together on this. I shared a photo a week ago suggesting how cool it would be if both the candidates went into the debate remembering the other was the image of God. My wall lit up like a Christmas tree, and not all with agreement…


  3. Wow. I worked for what sounds like a very similar organization in Washington 11 years ago, and what you write about the disjunction between motivations and methods exactly describes my experience. Exactly. At that time I would have said that I agreed with every one of my organization’s positions, and yet I found myself increasingly uncomfortable with the methods my bosses were comfortable employing to achieve our goals. When my contract was up, I left and didn’t look back. In fact, I think I’ve been harder on them (and the other “family groups”) than on almost anyone else. You’ve reminded me that I can and need to become more compassionate, more full of grace, more forgiving towards everyone in the way you describe–including my former employers. This is a good word. :)


    • Thanks Sharone. I think Campolo was as good an example as any of what it looks like to extend grace & acceptance toward those on the other side of the fence. He did that for me back in the day, so it’s the least I can do for those I disagree with…


  4. I loved this article, Ben.

    I had a neighbor in DC who worked at a similar organization, one interested in holding on to the heritage that the Christian right was creating. Every day he went there, every day they fought homosexuality, and every day he came home to look in the mirror at the attractive gay man.

    I hated that for him.


  5. Your testimony reminds me of a Wesley quote regarding politics:
    “I met those in our society who had votes in the ensuing election, and advised them, 1. To vote, without fee or reward, for the person they judged most worthy: 2. To speak no evil of the person they voted against: And, 3. To take care their spirits were not sharpened against those that voted on the other side.”

    I emailed you regarding Election Day Communion, but I never got a response from you. I thank God, though, that my family is part of a church with leadership that embraced the idea when I shared it with them. Thanks, again, for sharing it with us.


    • I’ve never seen that Wesley quote before, but absolutely love it. I’m saving it so I can pull it out every 2-4 years for… well, the rest of my life, in all likelihood. I don’t imagine the election day will ever come when it isn’t painfully relevant.

      Thank you so, so much for that quote. Truly.


  6. Thank you so much for this inspiring post, Ben. I saw it on a friend’s Facebook wall and recognized your name! Sounds like you are choosing to be a conscientious objector in the culture wars.


  7. Powerful stuff. Thank you so much for sharing your story of making things right with Tony, and thank you, too, for showing us the grace Tony extended to you. Thank you, especially now, for inspiring us to conduct ourselves as Christians in the midst of this election season–we need voices like yours! I’ll long remember your post, and will share it with others.
    Linda Thomas


  8. Clicking a “like” button here doesn’t go far enough. I remember you writing that booklet, but never knew some of the stories like this behind it. I think the one thing that Christians are waking up to slowly is that wherever you land on the issue of homosexuality, your actions related to it should still be consistent with Biblical mandates. It seems like we’ve forgotten that with a lot of the “A Christian doesn’t do X” emphasis that has become so prevalent in our century.


    • I do find it strange that even though homosexuality as we know it may not even be mentioned in Scripture (and if it is, only a handful of times), it has become seemingly THE defining issue for many Christians (myself included, once upon a time). This causes something of a problem, because Jesus and Paul both said THE defining issue is how we love our neighbor. (Jesus: all the law & prophets hang on this one command. Paul: love is the fulfillment of the law.) So the thing for which the biblical mandate is murky at best, we turn into a black-and-white issue. And the thing on which the Bible is painstakingly clear, we treat as if it were a murky issue, conditioned with all sorts of caveats, exceptions and “get out” clauses.

      But like you said, I think it’s changing slowly…and for the better.


  9. You have spoke the truth beautifully. This has been on my heart since the political season started and I have wondered if I am the only one who feels this way….It’s good to know I’m not :) Thank you voicing this!


    • Thanks Apryl. And for what it’s worth, you’re not. That’s what led a couple friends of mine to start something called Election Day Communion. To date, more than 700 churches have signed up to …so I think there are a lot of people who are ready to be done with all the polarization.


  10. Pingback: Tuesday is on its way… « Abnormal Anabaptist

  11. Pingback: this went thru my mind |

  12. Pingback: Food & Relief Friday: Pumpkin Brownies & Chalk Lines « free to be courageous

  13. It is so frustrating as I driive in my car. The sweet time of praise to the father is interrupted by hatred and disdain during hourly “news” segments and commentary. It’s my special daily worship that helps me stay kingdom focused. How can they not see the contradiction between the music and the words?


  14. Pingback: Weekly Wrap « Exploring Apprenticeship

  15. Pingback: How evangelical tribal gatekeepers operate: ‘I want you to go after Campolo’

  16. I have to agree with stimbop above – clicking “Like” isn’t enough. We can’t say we’re serving God’s goals and then turn around and not serve them his way. I love that Mr. Campolo was so gracious at the end. Can you imagine your former boss acting with such grace? There are some days I want to shout at people – “didn’t you read The Book?” By their fruits you will know them.


  17. Pingback: Linkathon 11/21, part 1 » Phoenix Preacher | Phoenix Preacher

  18. Pingback: Weekend link dump for November 25 – Off the Kuff

  19. Campolo & yourself must be better men than I could ever be. Conservative Christians have been responsible for things that I’ll never forgive, but I don’t have the right to do so in any event. One rarely hears of the actions I am referring to, & most who could articulate it better than I, have died. During the early years of the AIDS epidemic, they fiercely & successfully opposed the use of any public funds for research into HIV. The subsequent delay in the development of effective treatment options denied thousands even a fighting chance at survival. Through the years, I have buried 57 of the most remarkable men anyone could ever hope to know in life & have the privilege of calling friends. They may have died from the opportunistic infections & cancers in any event, but they were denied any opportunity to continue living.


  20. Pingback: And on the seventh day, he linked | Fraser Sherman's Blog

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s